Skip to Main Content

Conducting a Literature Review

What is Risk of Bias?

Conducted AFTER the review (literature review, systematic review etc.) to assess if the studies used have methodological flaws that skew the study conclusions and, therefore, the judgment.

  • NOT conducted at the abstract/ full-text consideration of scholarly/credible/peer-review content for a project. Even credible/scholarly/peer-review content may have risk-of-bias embedded in the study.
  • Measures the RISK of bias, NOT the existence of bias.
  • The measurement is done by asking methodological questions of the articles and assigning them a domain. Each domain is ranked with a number, stars, colors etc. Each piece is assigned an overall risk level after adding up the domain rankings.
  • It is different than critical appraisal tools such as PICOT. Those tools examine the effectiveness of clinical interventions in evidence-based practice.
  • Sometimes, the terms critical appraisal and risk-of-bias are treated as synonyms.  You can discern what is intended by attention to the outcome stated, such as evidence-based medicine (critical appraisal) or methodological assessment (risk of bias). 

How to Represent Risk of Bias

Results are often represented in graph form, like the "traffic light" graph below. The color represents the reviewer's conclusion about the risk of each type of bias in each study. 

From: https://learning.edanz.com/what-is-risk-of-bias-in-a-systematic-review/

 

Find 
Programs
Research Help
 Services

A-Z List of Databases

Accessing Other Libraries

Encyclopedias & Dictionaries

Faculty Resources

Library Homepage 

Library Orientation

Multimedia 

RefWorks

Statistics & Data Sets

Video Tutorials

Business & Technology

Doctoral Research Support

Education 

Nursing & Health Sciences

 

 

APA Support

Conducting a Literature Review

Copyright & Fair Use

Evidence-Based Practice

How to Evaluate Online Sources

Legal Resources

Research 101

Research Instruments

Scholarly Research Primer

 

Brainfuse Tutoring

Code of Conduct

Financial Aid

Helpdesk

Student Services